In life, it isn’t what you look at that matters. It’s what you see; and people only see what they are prepared to confront.
Riley Johnson was an only child, living with her mother and father. She spent almost all of her time at the piano in her house, playing wonderful music that her father composed for her. He loved music very much, but an injury to his hand when he was in his mid-twenties had forced him away from the piano. And when his daughter was old enough to begin to play, he was thrilled to see that she enjoyed it just as much as he once had. The music that he had written throughout his life, but had never been able to play, was finally able to be heard. And his daughter played it wonderfully. Their relationship together grew into an unbreakable bond. Riley loved her father more than anyone in the world, and their mutual love in music was what linked them together.
Almost everyone in the town knew Riley and her father. They were very friendly, and well-respected by all of their neighbors, and all of Riley’s classmates and their families. Her father was really involved with the school, and everyone knew that he was her father. The two looked so much like father and daughter that it would be impossible to mistake their relation. They had the same straight brunette hair, and deep brown eyes that reflected the light. And of course, they had the same long fingers that were perfect for piano.
Riley played in recitals every month, and always took home either the gold or silver with the music her father wrote for her. After every recital, Riley and her father would go out to the lake to celebrate. During the warmer months, they would wade out into the shallows, and skip the largest, flattest stones they could find, competing to see who could throw it farther. Her father won almost every time. During the winter months, when the lake was entirely frozen over, they would slowly venture out onto the solid ice, competing to see who would have the guts to take that one extra step. Riley almost always won those competitions, only ever turning back when she heard the faint cracking of the ice beneath her feet. Her father had nicknamed her his “little daredevil”, since she was always willing to take that extra step. And it wasn’t just in those trips to the lake. She took things one step further with everything in her life. But one day, in the middle of December, as the holiday spirit was spreading throughout the city, something went horribly wrong.
Riley’s Christmas piano recital was just finishing up, and she had strayed from the usual music that she played at the recitals, written by her father. Instead, she played a classic Christmas ballad. It was a festive recital, and was more about the after-party than the piano-playing itself, so there was no winner; and therefore, no reason to celebrate. Despite that, after the holiday luncheon, Riley and her father felt like celebrating.
They took their usual trip down to the lake, which held so many fond memories for them. Riley looked out across the vast expanse of pure snow. The lights opposite them on the lake, from the distant city across, could scarcely be seen through the onset of flurries floating down to the ground, resting carefully on the fragile surface of the ice. Riley noticed that the wind was blowing harder than usual, and a chill ran up her spine. She could feel the cold seeping into her bones, and her father noticed her shiver. Smiling, he hugged her, trying to give her some of his warmth.
“You sure you’re ready for this?” he asked.
“If by ‘this’ you mean win, then yeah, bring it on,” Riley joked.
Her father laughed kindly.
Riley took a few steps out onto the ice, and her father followed alongside her. One by one, they took step after step onto the solid ice, barely even hearing any noise under their feet.
Her father decided to stop, saying that he was as far as he was willing to go. But Riley continued, step after step, further and further out across the lake. Feeling particularly brave, she twirled around, giggling like she did when she was much younger. Facing her father, she walked backwards slowly, listening for any sign of cracking beneath her feet.
“It sure is solid this year,” she said, when suddenly, the ice gave way beneath her.
As the freezing cold water hit her body, Riley was shocked, unable even to scream. She couldn’t see, hear, or feel anything; only an intense numbness that shook her body, frightening her more than anything in the world ever had. A few minutes later, she passed out.
When she regained consciousness, she found herself in a hospital with a beeping monitor hooked up to her finger, assuring the doctors of her prolonged existence, and constant heart beat. Her head pounded, but she felt otherwise perfectly normal, only a bit foggy. As if she had awoken from a long dream. She looked next to her and saw her father sitting in a chair, smiling at her reassuringly.
“Dad, what happened?” she asked.
“You fell into the ice. I only got to you just in time.”
“You save my life.”
He nodded, reaching out to squeeze her hand.
The hospital attendants walked in, informing her that her mother had signed the necessary paperwork, and she was free to leave whenever she chose. The nurse said that her mother was waiting for her in the car just outside the doors to the hospital.
After thanking the nurse, Riley got up and walked out, her father by her side.
“How would you like to ride shotgun?” he asked.
Riley nodded, though a bit surprised. Her father never let her ride shotgun, unless it was just the two of them.
When Riley entered the car, her mother was oddly silent, and her blue eyes were red and puffy. It was apparent that she had been crying.
“Mom, it’s okay. I’m alright. Thanks to Dad,” Riley said, trying to help. She turned to the back seat and smiled at her father.
“I know sweetie, I know,” her mother said shakily, and the three of them headed home.
Riley continued to play piano, but her father wouldn’t write any more. He said that he’d lost inspiration, and just didn’t have it in him. Whenever he thought of his music, thoughts of what happened that night after the recital inevitably followed. So instead of working on new music, she just perfected the music she already knew. It drove her mother crazy, how constantly she played, but Riley felt comforted by it. Since she didn’t have any new songs to play, Riley stopped attending recitals, despite her father desperately trying to convince her to go. But it would be weird for her to go to recitals and then not visit the lake after, and there was no way she wanted to go back to the lake. Not after what happened.
Finally, almost a year after the incident, Riley decided to write something of her own. It was a sad, almost spooky song that was more complex than anything she’d tried to play before. It was a combination of a bunch of different tunes of the songs her father had played, but set in a different, diminished key. She spent all of her time working on the piece, and stopped paying any attention to school. Her grades started to drop, and her mother didn’t even do anything about it. After what had happened, it seemed that her mother had checked out of Riley’s life altogether, spending all of her time either working, or sitting silently, alone in her room. Even Riley’s father couldn’t do anything to shake her of her depression.
Riley believed that finishing this song would signify moving on, and forgetting about what had happened—or nearly happened—to her. She could go back to the way her life was before she nearly died, and even resume the monthly piano recitals. She had great confidence in this new song, and her father encouraged her constantly. Finally, the time came for Riley to present the piece to the public. She convinced her mother to set up a slot for her at the upcoming recital, and she felt that she was more prepared than ever.
Her mother dropped her off at her recital, and Riley stepped out of the car, onto the sidewalk. Nervously, she looked up at the tall, dark building as if seeing it in a new light. She had not visited the hall in over a year, and she began to lose all confidence in her song, doubting every decision she had made up until that point. Suddenly her father appeared beside her, and rested his hand on her shoulder.
“Riley, you are the most wonderful pianist I have ever heard, and your music is beautiful. You have no reason to be nervous.”
Taking a deep breath, Riley nodded, knowing in her heart that what her father said was true. She took one more look at the building, with its stained-glass windows, and its church-like intimidation. She walked through the front doors, down the aisle, past the hundreds upon hundreds of seats that would soon be filled with adoring parents, siblings, and friends of those playing, and up onto the stage. She looked out upon the empty seats with a feeling of pride. Pride in herself, and in her own talents, but most of all, pride in her father. He was the most wonderful man she knew, and her true hero. He not only showed her the way through life, and helped fuel her one true passion, but he had saved her life. He was always there when she needed him the most, and she had no doubt in her mind that he wouldn’t pull through for her today.
Riley walked over to the grand piano in the center of the stage. Its slick black cover shone, reflecting the light with a virtuous radiance. She ran her finger softly along the black and white keys, feeling their familiarity, and the ease at which her mind processed them. They weren’t just a series of white and black buttons that you push to make music; they were a sequence of sounds that, when connected in just the right way, created the most lovely, eerie, sad, beautiful sounds she could ever imagine. But when she looked at the piano she didn’t just hear music, she felt her father’s loving gaze, his approval, his admiration in her skill. And that, she realized, was why she treasured it so much.
An hour later, she was back stage, listening to the final chords of the song that was played before her own. The audience stood up, applauding generously the music from the third movement of Moonlight Sonata, a Beethoven classic.
“And now, ladies and gentlemen, here to present to you a song of her own, composed entirely herself, is young Miss Riley Johnson!”
A polite, quiet applause followed the announcement, and she walked out onto the stage. Riley’s chocolate brown hair was curled into ringlets, and pulled back, out of her face, so that it would not get in her way. She wore a sleek, strapless black dress that travelled all the way to the floor, and long, webbed black gloves. As she walked on stage, she immediately began to search the audience for her father, but she instead saw her mother sitting alone, the chairs on either side of her occupied by strangers. Regardless, Riley continued toward the piano, flashing a confident smile, and sat on the bench behind it, facing partially away from the audience.
She set the metronome to a slow 80, and counted herself in. One, two, three, and… The music flew through the ends of her fingertips like silk, weaving a sad, pure melody. As the song went on, the mood began to change, and weave between sadness and fear, and everyone in the audience who knew Riley’s story understood at once that it was a song about what happened to her all those months ago. As she finished up the long piece, Riley stood and looked into the applauding audience, seeing her mother. Even from all that distance, Riley could make out the tears that were running down her mother’s cheeks, and whether they were tears of sadness or tears of happiness, she could not tell.
And then she saw, at the back of the audience, standing in the aisle, her father. His presence reminded her of her motivation for the song, and so she took the microphone and said, loudly and clearly to the audience, “This song was for my inspiration, my admiration, and my hero: my father.”
After the recital, as strangers congratulated her, she noticed her neighbor, her mother’s good friend, smiling at her. Riley walked over to her, surprised at her presence there, but before she could say anything, the woman smiled at her.
“That was beautiful Riley, and I just loved how you dedicated it to your father. His death was ever so tragic, and I am very sorry for you and your mother.”
Riley was about to thank her when the words processed in her mind.
His death?
“I’m sorry Mrs. Marisol, but what do you mean?”
“Oh, my apologies dear, I don’t mean to bring up past difficulties. I was only meaning how he died saving you, at the lake last year.”
Riley frowned. “But Mrs. Marisol, my father isn’t dead! He saved my life, but he lived; he even came here tonight!”
Now her neighbor was puzzled. Shaking her head, she looked at Riley as if she had gone mad. “No dear, your father died that night. He can’t be here, that’s not possible. I think you’re confused.”
“No, no…” Riley trailed off, turning away, unable to believe what she was hearing.
Her father had helped her with her song! He had been there with her at the hospital, and had smiled at her after her performance. He had encouraged her throughout the past year, and helped her to see her true purpose in life. Her father was alive, she was sure of it. What was Mrs. Marisol talking about?
Riley turned back to her neighbor, and saw that she had gone off somewhere. A moment later, the woman returned with her mother at her side.
“Riley…” her mother began.
“Mom! Tell Mrs. Marigold the truth; tell her she’s wrong. Daddy’s not dead, he lived. Tell her!”
Her mother looked at her sadly, shaking her head.
“Mom, tell her!”
“Sweetie, your father is dead. He died a year ago, at the lake. He died saving you.”
Riley shook her head.
“Riley, what’s wrong with you? Why are you being like this?” Her mother’s eyes were swelling up with tears.
“NO!” Riley shouted at her mother, running away from her, from Mrs. Marigold, and from everyone. She ran out the doors of the hall, down the street, and toward the lake. She didn’t stop running until she reached the edge of the frozen water.
Riley picked up a chunk of ice and threw it as far as she could out onto the lake, screaming as loudly as she could manage. She thought about the past year, and all of her interactions with her father. She thought about how he had hugged her, smiled at her, patted her on the shoulder, and squeezed her hand reassuringly. But then she thought about how he would seem to just appear by her side when she needed him. How he would never go to work, and would never really talk to anyone but her.
She broke down crying, and sunk to the floor, her black dress collecting snow from the ground.
“Riley!”
She looked up, and saw her father, standing out on the ice, waving to her.
“Riley, I’m here, look: I’m not dead,” he said calmly, comfortingly. “You’re mother’s crazy, she’s not thinking straight. But I’m here. And guess what?”
She forced herself to speak. “What?”
“I bet you can’t get farther than me,” he teased lightly.
Riley wiped the tears away from her eyes, stood up, and brushed the snow off her dress. She smiled, realizing that she had been right all along. Her father wasn’t dead; he was right there, calling to her.
“Is that a challenge?” she asked, managing to laugh through the tears.
Her father raised his eyebrows, and she knew that meant yes. If her father was out that far, she knew that she could go that far as well, and so without a second thought, she raced out onto the ice, wanting to embrace her father, to feel his existence, and to prove beyond a doubt in her mind that he was real. When she was a few feet away from him, she slowed to a walk.
“Riley!”
“Yeah, I’m coming.”
“Riley, what are you doing?” he yelled, sounding entirely panicky.
She frowned. “Exactly what you told me to. I’m coming to you.”
“Riley, stop!”
She suddenly realized the voice wasn’t coming from her father, it was coming from behind her. She turned around and saw her mother standing nearly fifty yards away on the shore, her eyes as wide as quarters.
“Come back,” her mother begged. “Please.”
“No Mom, you’re crazy. Dad’s alive. He’s right here.”
Riley went to point to her father, but as she turned back to face him, she saw nothing but the great expanse of the lake, with the faint lights from the city all the way across the lake.
“But…” Riley trailed off.
She couldn’t believe it, but then she saw an opening in the ice, and realized with horror that her father must have slipped through, as she had.
“Dad!” she screamed, running toward the hole.
But as she got closer, the ice beneath her began to crack, and she heard her mother screaming as it gave way beneath her. Riley heard her father’s voice calling to her, saying her name, and she felt his firm grasp on her shoulder as she sunk into the depths of the dark, cold lake.
